| 'Buena
mano'
THE WEEK before
last, I bought a used cellar phone from one of the many vendors in
Virra Mall Center in the Greenhills commercial center in San Juan
City. Within two days, it broke down but I wasn't too worried. The
vendor had given me a receipt and assured me I could exchange a
defective product within a week.
So off I went one morning, catching the cell-phone dealers around
10 a.m. as they were setting up their booth. Ever so pleasantly, I
went over to the booth where I had bought the defective phone and
showed the vendor my receipt. I was aghast when she snapped back
in Tagalog, "Come back at 11. We haven't had our buena mano
yet."
For those not familiar with the term, "buena mano" is
Spanish for "good hand." Many cultures, not just our
own, have this magical belief that a good sale -- a transaction
involving the hands -- at the start of the day brings in more
customers and more transactions. "Good" is defined in
many ways. It can be a large transaction, which means more money.
Or it can be an early sale, which means you won't have to wait
long for succeeding customers.
The incident at Virra Mall made me realize there was still another
definition of "good" and this was an "easy"
transaction, one done without any acrimony. This was why the
dealers generally try to avoid handling complaints. When they
asked me to come back, what they meant was that they wanted to
make a sale first, the buena mano, rather than deal with a bad
mouth.
I was slightly irritated and offered to make the buena mano by
buying a mobile headset. But no, the woman insisted I come back at
11, explaining that she had to first finish setting up her booth.
Again, the anthropologist in me took over and I tried to be
understanding. I knew there were all kinds of rituals involved
here. It wasn't just a matter of arranging the phones and
accessories in the glass cabinets. They had to put money in the
shelves as well -- again a magical practice that presumes money,
like the buena mano, generates more money.
But even as I processed this magical logic, I knew I had to say my
piece. I retorted, voice slightly raised, that I had to go to work
and couldn't wait around another hour. I told them that as a
compromise, I would return in half an hour and they better deal
with my case. After all, I pointed out, they had sold me a
defective phone and they owed me.
I returned half an hour later, and this time it was another vendor
who responded. She was there earlier in the morning but had been
quiet. This time, all smiles, she apologized for her companion,
claiming that she wasn't very diplomatic and that they'd scolded
her in the past for that.
I nodded and apologized, too, for my "outburst." (My
friends know a Mike Tan outburst is all too often quite
ineffective, sometimes even too friendly.) But I did add, knowing
that she and most other vendors in Virra Mall were Muslim, that
rudeness and the flaring of tempers weren't right, especially
since it was Ramadan, the Islamic month for fasting, prayer and
reflection.
As we went about picking a replacement phone, I talked about the
need to be honest with customers. I've received so many complaints
from friends who have been in similar predicaments, ending up with
lemons and vendors refusing to exchange the phones. I told my
dealer that I knew used cell-phones were always problematic, and
that sometimes defects don't emerge until after a few days, which
was fine, as long as they honored the agreement, in a written
receipt, to exchange the problem phone within seven days.
There is a lesson to pick up from all this, one that is not
limited to Ramadan and Muslim entrepreneurs, and this is the need
to counter buena mano as a magical belief. Unfortunately, many
Filipino business people still limit the idea of buena mano to an
exchange of money at the beginning of the day, one which they
think will automatically bring in more money.
It's time we -- Muslims, Christians, Buddhists, whatever --
expanded this notion of buena mano to refer to business ethics. A
"good hand" is an honest hand. As I explained to the
Virra Mall vendor, who has since become my friend, if you offer
fair deals and efficient customer support, then you have a buena
mano.
The buena mano is not in the buying itself, but in the goodwill
and trust generated by the vendor's own ethical practices,
together with graciousness and a sense of service. All that comes
together to keep the cash register ringing, in terms of returning
customers and the friends they bring along.
So, if you end up with a defective product bought from one of the
many "tiangge" (bazaars), you might want to go first
thing in the morning to settle this. Many Filipino entrepreneurs
will avoid having to deal with arguments early in the day and will
settle amicably. But don't stop with that. If they respond well,
compliment them, and if they don't, stand up for your rights. No
matter what you do though, do plug in the need to develop a new
buena mano appropriate to our times.
|