| 21
November 2002
Ring tones as
social capital
THE BUZZWORD
these days in development jargon is "social capital,"
which is now touted by such agencies as the World Bank as an
important key to development.
The term dates back to the 1970s, and is used by anthropologists
and sociologists to refer to the social networks as well as norms
of obligation and trust. The idea here is that it takes more than
financial capital to move a community forward. People need to be
convinced to work together, and to pool together knowledge and
skills. Without this, all the monetary capital in the world will
not be very useful.
My favorite definition of social capital comes from two South
African researchers, Tony Barnett and Alan Whiteside, who offer
this succinct description: "stored trust, understanding and
information."
I'm particularly interested in this idea of "stored
information." One can imagine a community, or even an entire
nation, having a kind of data bank of knowledge and skills which
grows with time. All societies have this, but the ways of
transmitting this accumulated knowledge will vary, ranging from
proverbs and riddles to books and, today, compact discs.
Preserving--and transmitting--knowledge is important because it
saves on having to reinvent the wheel. Instead of starting from
scratch, you pick up from where previous generations left off, to
improve and expand.
The indigenous portions of this social capital are especially
important because you have knowledge that evolved in response to
local conditions and may therefore be the more appropriate for
solving problems.
This is where I have fears about the Philippines. We are already
handicapped, compared to many other Asian countries, by having a
fairly short history as "the Philippines" and as
"Filipinos." Our oldest churches, for example, are less
than 400 years. In China, a 400-year-old temple would be
considered "new" since "old" means a thousand
years or so.
There's also a very more conscious effort, among many other Asian
countries, to transmit and accumulate social capital. I once had a
tour guide who proudly told me her four-year-old son, who had only
started nursery, could recite poems from the Tang dynasty, which
goes back a thousand years. This is not surprising. Go into a
Chinese bookstore and you will find shelf after shelf of very old
books in all kinds of adaptations, including comic-book versions
for very young children. Older Chinese, who memorized the poems in
their childhood, get the next generation off to an early start by
reciting these poems much like they would sing a lullaby.
I don't see enough of that here. We have children's books
certainly, and outfits like Aklat Adarna do a good job in weaving
in local folk tales. But we need a more sustained effort to
propagate older traditions.
This is not a matter of nostalgia. Having links to the past makes
us appreciate ourselves more, and helps to wean us from our
over-dependence on America and the West. Just look at the use of
medicinal plants as an example. We buy up all kinds of imported
"natural products" but fail to develop our own, because
there hasn't been enough interest in documenting and developing
local plants, or traditional medicine in general.
There are so many channels for accumulating social capital. I know
this will sound almost strange, but even ring tones can be one
such venue. Look at Globe and Smart's available ring tones for
download and you'll find everything from the Beatles to Eminem--everything
foreign, that is. There are a few contemporary Filipino tunes but
none of the older Filipino songs. A few months back, when Lucio
San Pedro passed away, I realized you couldn't get his "Ugoy
sa Duyan" as a ring tone. No wonder one TV commentator,
attempting a eulogy to this great composer, referred to his piece
as "Unggoy sa Duyan.''
I checked around at UP and found a musical score for the song, and
then converted the notes into a ring tone. Since then I've shared
it with friends, usually people who hear my phone ringing and
recognize the tune. That recognition is at least a consolation.
Even more encouraging is that some of them tell me their teenage
children have also requested the ring tone.
I'd like to think that's one way of contributing to social
capital, not so much a bunch of musical notes than a sense of
pride in our own culture. Note, too, that there's a political
angle to "Ugoy"--If people ask, you should explain it
was composed during the Japanese occupation, the plaintive
lullaby-like tune being a metaphor for a nation in distress.
There are many other examples of lost opportunities for passing on
social capital. I particularly like the way Indonesians tap older
terms to describe modern technologies. A phone booth is a "wartel."
If you're looking for an Internet cafe, look for "warnet."
The terms are hybrids: "warung telefon" and "warung
Internet," warung being the equivalent of our kubo or hut.
Last year, taking one of their commuter trains, I was intrigued by
vendors hawking, "sarong remote, sarong remote." No one
seemed to be peddling the cloth wraparounds one associates with
sarong. It turned out a sarong remote was a case for the remote
control unit. I presume they now have sarong mobile.
Indonesia's phone cards come in a wide variety, most of which are
colorful designs adapted from Indonesian arts and crafts. In
contrast, Philippine phone cards feature basketball players, movie
stars, Winnie the Pooh or, worse, drab company logos.
Our much-touted artistic flair is, unfortunately, mainly
imitative, and this lack of originality spills over into our
political culture and our economic system. We consume or ape other
societies' creations and stifle local initiatives. Building social
capital is not a matter of stagnating and living in the past. It's
harnessing the creativity and imagination of past generations so
we can catapult ourselves into an exciting future.
|